“Astounded” Regulator Slams PG&E Over Power Cut

“You guys failed on so many levels on pretty simple stuff,”


California Public Utilities Commission President Marybel Batjer, center rear, and commissioners listen as representatives of Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E), seated at bottom, speak during a meeting at CPUC headquarters in San Francisco, Friday, Oct. 18, 2019. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)


By JANIE HAR Associated Press

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — California’s top regulator excoriated top executives of the state’s largest utility even as Pacific Gas & Electric repeatedly said they know they failed to meet public expectations when the company cut the power to more than 2 million people last week.

Marybel Batjer, president of the California Public Utilities Commission, called the emergency meeting Friday and ordered the executives to attend and explain themselves. She said she was “absolutely astounded” by what she thought were simple preparedness steps the utility could have taken.

“You guys failed on so many levels on pretty simple stuff,” Batjer said.

PG&E officials, even as they repeatedly apologized for their shortcomings in execution, defended their decision to cut power to more than 700,000 customer accounts in advance of dangerous winds that could have sparked wildfires.

“We actually didn’t have any catastrophic fires in northern and central California; that was the sole intent,” said Bill Johnson, CEO of PG&E Corp.

Pacific Gas and Electric Company (PG&E) CEO Bill Johnson listens to speakers during a California Public Utilities Commission meeting in San Francisco, Friday, Oct. 18, 2019. (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)

Gov. Gavin Newsom has blasted the San Francisco-based utility for what he called decades of mismanagement. Critics of the for-profit utility renewed calls to break up the company.

For much of the meeting, which lasted more than four hours, PG&E executives insisted they only had the public’s safety in mind when they cut off power. They promised to do better.

The company’s website had 1.7 million user requests an hour when it normally logs 7,000, officials said.

Andy Vesey, a PG&E executive, added that they did not think broadly enough and underestimated the needs of their customers and local governments. “We have to develop a mindset, or culture, of anticipation,” he said.

PG&E announced around 2 p.m. on Oct. 8 that it would be shutting off power at midnight to parts of northern and central California, saying that high wind forecasts could damage equipment and spark wildfires.

Panicked residents stood in long lines at supermarkets, hardware stores and gas stations, rushing to buy ice, coolers, flashlights and batteries to make sure their cars had gas.

The outages paralyzed parts of a state that has the fifth-largest economy in the world. Schools and universities canceled classes, and some businesses closed. Customers complained of overloaded call centers and a website that kept crashing.

FILE – In this Wednesday, Oct. 9, 2019, file photo, Carlos Lama of Bayside Cafe, which was among businesses to lose power due to Pacific Gas & Electric Corp’s public safety power shutoff, uses an LED lamp and light from his phone at the counter of the restaurant in Sausalito, Calif. California’s largest utility pledged to improve communications but reminded state regulators that its “difficult decision” to pre-emptively shut off power to more than 2 million people last week may have prevented deadly wildfires. (Alan Dep/Marin Independent Journal via AP, File)

“It’s not enough to do better in the future, when the harms were predicted and known,” said Melissa Kasnitz, legal director of the Center for Accessible Technology. “Real people experienced real fear.”

Wildfires in California caused by downed power lines and other utility equipment sparked fires in 2017 and 2018, including the Camp Fire last year that nearly wiped out the town of Paradise and killed 85 people.

PG&E said Monday that its systems were damaged in more than 100 places, and that those were spots that could have been a potential source of ignition for a wildfire.

Johnson, the CEO, said the utility will get better with each new pre-emptive outage as it works to upgrade its equipment so blackouts affect fewer people.

On Friday, Johnson suggested to Gov. Gavin Newsom in a letter that state leaders may want to consider having a state entity decide whether to shut off power in the future. Johnson said at the PUC meeting that he was not trying to offload responsibility, but that Californians may want to have the discussion given deep skepticism of the utility’s motives.

As for Newsom’s call for rebates to customers, Johnson said they are considering the idea but that could set “a dangerous precedent that any time the power goes out you might have some rebate or other thing.”

FILE – In this Friday, Oct. 11, 2019 file photo, a bystander watches the Saddleridge fire in Sylmar, Calif. California’s largest utility Pacific Gas & Electric Corp pledged to improve communications but reminded state regulators that its “difficult decision” to pre-emptively shut off power to more than 2 million people last week may have prevented deadly wildfires. (AP Photo/David Swanson, File)

Berkeley resident and disability rights advocate Marg Hall said Friday before the meeting that the outages are more than an inconvenience for some people with disabilities and the elderly.

“Friends, that even if their power wasn’t shut off, suffered health consequences from the stress of knowing that they were going to be abandoned,” she said.

On Friday, Newsom appointed Caroline Thomas Jacobs as the first director of the state’s new Wildfire Safety Division, which was created earlier this year and tasked with approving utilities’ wildfire mitigation plans and connecting them with independent experts to assess the safety of electrical equipment.


Associated Press staff writer Kathleen Ronayne contributed from Sacramento, California.

All contents © copyright 2019 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.


Check Also

KNP Complex Fire

Four Injured by Falling Tree at KNP Complex Fire in CA

THREE RIVERS, Calif. (AP) — Four people injured when a tree fell ...